Choosing a Compact RV or Camper for Retirement Travel
An article I posted a while back about our solution for cheap retirement travel — a small RV — continues to receive a lot of traffic. So I’m going to share our experience making this purchase to provide my best tips for buying an RV.
Nearly 10% of U.S. households own an RV of some sort, and the number is rising. Of households that don’t own an RV, almost 15% express some interest in purchasing one in the future, according to a University of Michigan study.
Other articles of mine focus on operating costs for using an RV, so here I’m going to discuss some of the issues around the RV purchase decision.
Note: Even if you’re not very interested in RVs, you might enjoy reading the next section for some thoughts on retirement living. It details a few of the general lessons learned from our RV experience….
Lessons on Retirement Living
Before we delve into some details of choosing and purchasing an RV, let me abstract a few lessons learned about retirement living, from my time in and around RVs:
Travel in Retirement
A big part of retirement for many is extensive travel. But travel can be expensive.
An RV is one approach to cheaper retirement travel, but there are many others. You could house swap, work for room and board, teach English overseas, stay with friends, or travel in the off-season, for example.
Whatever your style, unless you have unlimited resources, it’s wise to come up with some cheap angle for retirement travel.
A Lesson In Downsizing
An RV is a study in downsizing. Some people might see that as a hardship, but anybody who’s lived in one can tell you it’s not.
You realize how little is truly needed to be happy. In fact, being happy might be easier, the less “stuff” you have around. And that’s a feeling worth achieving whatever your retired habitat turns out to be.
Lastly, owning an RV is one strategy for being able to downshift your lifestyle relatively easily and quickly. Given the state of the world, especially if you are an early retiree, it is wise to have some strategy in mind for adjusting your lifestyle, should the future not go as planned.
You hope not to need it, but nobody can predict 30-40 years into the future. Thinking ahead about ways to significantly reduce your expenses could make it much less painful to adapt to changes should the need arise, temporarily, or permanently.
And now for some particulars on the why’s and how’s of purchasing a small RV….
Why Buy an RV?
There are a number of reasons to own an RV motorhome or camper. For some, like us, it is a natural extension of the tent, truck, and van camping we’ve done over the years. But it is a bit more comfortable and flexible, as we get older.
Camping in Comfort
For others, RV’ing is an easy introduction to the camping experience. An RV can also function as a second vehicle, a second home, a guest room, for tailgating or picnicking, and for traveling to shows or large events.
Modern RVs are plenty comfortable for all but the most discerning travelers. Fully equipped kitchens and bathrooms are standard. Even our small rig has hot and cold running water, gas heat, and air conditioning.
We’ve been reasonably comfortable camping in conditions ranging from freezing to around 90 degrees outside. Larger, more expensive RVs have even more finely regulated heating/cooling systems.
Without a doubt, one of the prime appeals of an RV is the flexibility. You can go wherever you want, whenever you want, without worrying about advance reservations, schedules, lines, or baggage.
We have done a number of trips that involved linking together stays with family and friends, camping in remote areas, transporting gear, taking on and offloading family members who were flying for portions of the trip — all with a minimum of pre-planning.
This would have been impossible to accomplish at anything like the same cost using conventional transportation.
A compact RV is a tool for more affordable vacations, however you must use it wisely to realize all the benefits. Studies have shown that families can spend up to 59 percent less when traveling by RV. But I doubt many people realize those kinds of savings, especially if they own large RVs and travel less often. My previous article reviews our own travel expenses in more detail.
Tips for Buying an RV
There are several kind of RVs and campers, and I’ll provide a quick introduction here.
Your first decision is whether to own an all-in-one motorhome or a tow-behind 5th wheel/travel trailer. I’ve always loved the simplicity and security of a motorhome (you don’t have to step outside the vehicle at night to go to bed when you’re traveling).
But if you already own and need a truck, then a camper you can pull behind makes lots of sense. Another advantage to towing is being able to unhitch and use the truck for local transportation once you reach your destination. (Only the very smallest motorhomes, like our van-based unit, are very practical as local transportation.)
If you are going to pull behind, my sense is that 5th wheels (trailers that use a heavier, rotating coupling to the tow vehicle) are roomier and more stable to tow, but I claim no great expertise in this area.
Types of RVs or Campers
Motorhome RVs break down into several classes:
RVs are built on a bus-like chassis. These are the big rigs of the road. New prices typically start in the 6 digits, and they can be as comfortable, and as well-appointed, as the finest homes.
Class A’s are impressive vehicles, and it’s great fun browsing through new and used models to see all the clever living ideas. But you need to be realistic about their role in your retirement picture, especially if frugality is an element of your retired life.
Class A’s are the most expensive RVs to own and operate. In most cases, they could save you money as a home replacement, but not as a vacation vehicle.
RVs are an alternative if you need the space of a Class A for full-time or extended living, but want to economize. The Class C’s are built on a truck or van chassis, which makes them somewhat cheaper.
The original body is cut away and replaced with a much larger living compartment. New models can be found from about $50K-$60K and up.
They can have most of the same features as a Class A, though there is typically a bit less living space (the cockpit is usually not available as living area), and less storage space (the rigs sit lower to the ground).
RVs are built on a van chassis, using the original body or only small extensions to it. These are the smallest full-featured RVs on the road.
Some are almost indistinguishable from a conversion van, yet contain the full complement of RV luxuries: stove, fridge, microwave, hot/cold water, shower, TV, gas heat, AC. Some of the fancier units contain “slide-outs” to give you a few extra feet of living space.
Unfortunately “smaller” doesn’t mean “cheaper” in the case of Class B RVs. Because they contain most of the same features as their larger counterparts, but must be constructed in a tighter, less uniform space (our Class B contains impressive custom cabinet work contoured to the sides of the van body), expect to pay more for them than the larger Class C’s.
Class B’s start in the $80-$90K range. On the other hand, these RVs can typically be serviced in any auto shop — so you don’t have the expense or inconvenience of taking it to a specialized truck or RV shop.
For more about these smallest RVs, check out the Class B Forum.
Platforms for Compact RVs
All motorized RVs essentially have two manufacturers: one of the major auto companies makes the chassis, then an RV manufacturer (there are many of these) takes delivery of that chassis and constructs an RV on top of it.
For the larger RVs the chassis is a bare-bones affair and the RV takes shape around it. For the smaller RVs, usually some or most of the chassis body is reused, possibly with some extensions or cutouts.
I have a slight preference for the Ford chassis on smaller RVs. We’ve owned several Fords over the years and they’ve been solid vehicles. The cockpits are cleanly designed and fairly consistent from vehicle to vehicle.
Ford is a commonly used RV chassis, so you may see more choices in Ford-based models. But if you have a preference for Chrysler or GM, I don’t know of any hard facts to dissuade you, so shop for those.
The upstart RV chassis is the diesel Mercedes Sprinter, the second generation of which made its debut in early 2007. Its tall, narrow profile is a common sight in commercial cargo operations these days, and the Sprinter is rapidly gaining ground in the RV industry as well. (We probably would have bought a Sprinter-based RV, except that there were virtually no used ones available when we purchased years ago.)
The Sprinter’s most compelling feature? A 6-cylinder diesel engine with amazing fuel mileage: generally in the low 20 miles per gallon for a loaded rig. That’s three or four times what a conventional RV gets. And it’s about 7 or more miles to the gallon than our relatively fuel efficient E350-based rig.
Though keep in mind that the relative cost of diesel fuel fluctuates, so the increased fuel efficiency may not help your pocketbook out as much as you might like.
Top RV Manufacturers
If you begin shopping for a compact RV, you’ll soon run into two prominent manufacturers, both Canadian: Roadtrek and Pleasure-Way. These companies occupy the top two spots in the Class B retail market share according to Statistical Surveys Inc. They both make fine products.
Roadtrek appears to be the slightly larger and more high-end company, with historically a more extensive product line. Pleasure-Way might be a little less expensive. If you find a floor plan that suits you from either company, you won’t go wrong.
We own a Pleasure-Way and love it. (Though we’re still a bit inhibited about that name — maybe something doesn’t quite translate from the Canadian?) At the time we bought, Pleasure-Way offered the only widely available small RV with a completely private bathroom, a big plus.
Our Pleasure-Way is a beautifully and cleverly crafted machine that has functioned well on more than a dozen major road trips now, spread over 3 years and 40,000+ miles.
Now that the world is focused on the cost and availability of energy, and compact RVs are here to stay, the other mainstream manufacturers are jumping on the wagon and offering their own Class B and related models. Winnebago has its Era and View lines, among others, for example, which may be a bit larger than the typical offerings from the Canadians.
It’s probably safe to say that every major RV manufacturer will have an entry in this category before long. And the good news, so far, is that they mostly appear to be of high-quality. Perhaps it’s just too difficult to build something shoddy in such a small space.
That brings us to a discussion of some key features….
Evaluating Key RV Features
I won’t offer a complete rundown on every system in the common RV here. They are, after all, effectively a house combined with a motor vehicle.
So your experience with buying cars and houses will stand you in good stead. And a little additional research and education to supplement those skills will be time well spent.
An RV has gas, electrical, plumbing, and HVAC systems that are not so different from their land-based counterparts. At a minimum, you want to make sure these are in good working order and reasonably easy to operate.
But let me touch on a few specific components, to pass along what wisdom we’ve gained:
I was once a humble tent camper who frowned on those uncouth RV generators. But I’ve changed my tune a bit. Today’s generators are reasonably quiet and burn tiny amounts of fuel compared to larger engines.
Used intelligently and considerately (only during posted hours at campgrounds), they are an essential tool for efficient life on the road. They give you AC power at the touch of a button, and there are certain appliances — microwaves and air conditioners — that won’t run any other way.
Generators also let you recharge your house batteries and battery-powered gadgets while off the grid. A final bonus of a generator is that it can double for backup power at home: We ran an extension cord indoors from ours last year when a storm took out the power for several days, and it saved a fridge-load of food.
An inverter is an electronic device that converts 12 volt DC power to the 110 volt AC power used by household appliances. Most RVs come with one behind the scenes. Make sure yours does, and exposes some receptacles you can use.
It’s a huge convenience to be able to recharge laptops and cell phones without needing any special adapters, without even needing to run the generator, such as at night in quiet campgrounds.
An always-running gas/electric fridge is a huge convenience on the road. Perhaps one of the main selling points of an RV is being able to transport and eat your own fresh food.
Don’t be put off by the seeming small size of RV units compared to your gargantuan household model. Our 3.8 cubic foot Dometic fridge has been a workhorse.
We have yet to need more space: we routinely fit about a week’s worth of cold groceries. A bit of unpacking and repacking and some attention to sequencing will make it work.
A microwave is another huge convenience on the road, from heating up leftovers to brewing a quick cup of coffee or tea (you can save a fortune on Starbucks). Safe to say every modern RV comes with a microwave, but make sure yours is functional and conveniently located.
To each his own, but we use ours surprisingly little on the road. Even though we love music, and watch plenty of movies at home, there never seems to be enough time on the road.
There is always so much else to do. When nighttime rolls around, we are tired from a day of outdoor adventure.
Another component we rarely use is our roll-out awning. It seems like a great idea and looks beautiful in photos.
We never seem to stay in one place long enough. Perhaps that is a downside of needing our small RV for local transportation.
Or maybe by the time it’s hot enough to need the awning, we are generally inside running the AC. Or maybe it’s that we just don’t sit around that much….
With long periods parked in the sun, punctuated by heavy hauling in between, RV tires take a beating. Our off-brand set died in disturbing fashion after only about 10,000 miles.
The four pricey Michelin’s I replaced them with are showing virtually no wear after two years, and are expected to go 90,000 miles total. When the time comes, buy quality tires: it’s worth the peace of mind.
The RV Purchase Process – New vs. Used
In my opinion, used is the only way to buy an RV. They are big-ticket items, with such a large first year depreciation (reportedly from 25% to 40%), and such a plentiful pre-owned supply, that it only makes sense to buy used. After all, that’s how most of us buy our homes.
If you aren’t comfortable checking out the rig yourself, you can pay a competent RV mechanic to do the job for you. And once you spend a few nights in your new quarters, you’ll feel like it was always yours.
We found our van advertised on eBay. Other prominent places to find used RVs are at RV Trader and your local Camping World. If you’re anywhere near New Mexico (or even if not, because they’ll pay your airfare under certain conditions), check out Vantastic Vans, a dealer specializing in both new and used small RVs.
Our van was offered by an obviously established dealer in another state, so I was reasonably confident doing the transaction online. I emailed them copies of various documents plus a $1,000 deposit via PayPal, and the rig was ours. We flew out a week later with a certified check to conclude the deal.
Inspecting Your RV
I had with me an extensive inspection checklist and did not plan to turn over the check until the van met our expectations. When we arrived we went right to work: I crawled over, around, and under the unit and inspected everything.
We exercised every system onboard. We:
- fired up the fridge and stove
- ran the microwave
- played music and watched videos
- flushed the toilet
- unrolled the awning
- ran the gas heat. (The air conditioning was already running constantly because it was over 100 degrees outside!)
When it was all over we had found a number of significant but fixable problems. Our trip was delayed for a couple days while the dealer addressed them all, at their expense, including reimbursing the extra days on our rental car.
In the end they felt a little beat up, but we got the mint condition vehicle that was advertised. And they got paid.
Final Thoughts on Buying an RV
RVs are houses on wheels. They are a bit different from land-based homes, neither better nor worse. These modern campers aren’t particularly complex — using relatively old technology compared to most of our digital toys. But any system that runs only occasionally can develop some problems. Expect a shakedown period after you take possession, before you get everything working and customized to your taste.
In the end, it will likely all be worth it. We have no regrets about our choice of a compact RV motorhome for retirement travel. We feel it has already paid for itself, with a dozen memorable vacations, and the promise of many more….
* * *
- The Best Retirement Calculators can help you perform detailed retirement simulations including modeling withdrawal strategies, federal and state income taxes, healthcare expenses, and more. Can I Retire Yet? partners with two of the best.
- Free Travel or Cash Back with credit card rewards and sign up bonuses.
- Monitor Your Investment Portfolio
- Sign up for a free Personal Capital account to gain access to track your asset allocation, investment performance, individual account balances, net worth, cash flow, and investment expenses.
- Our Books
* * *
[The founder of CanIRetireYet.com, Darrow Kirkpatrick relied on a modest lifestyle, high savings rate, and simple passive index investing to retire at age 50 from a career as a civil and software engineer. He has been quoted or published in The Wall Street Journal, MarketWatch, Kiplinger, The Huffington Post, Consumer Reports, and Money Magazine among others. His books include Retiring Sooner: How to Accelerate Your Financial Independence and Can I Retire Yet? How to Make the Biggest Financial Decision of the Rest of Your Life.]
* * *
Disclosure: Can I Retire Yet? has partnered with CardRatings for our coverage of credit card products. Can I Retire Yet? and CardRatings may receive a commission from card issuers. Other links on this site, like the Amazon, NewRetirement, Pralana, and Personal Capital links are also affiliate links. As an affiliate we earn from qualifying purchases. If you click on one of these links and buy from the affiliated company, then we receive some compensation. The income helps to keep this blog going. Affiliate links do not increase your cost, and we only use them for products or services that we’re familiar with and that we feel may deliver value to you. By contrast, we have limited control over most of the display ads on this site. Though we do attempt to block objectionable content. Buyer beware.