A Sneaky Tax Strategy for Wealthy Old Investors
Hey everyone! Are you ready to file your taxes? The IRS starts accepting tax returns today! (January 23, 2023.) As for me, I am not ready at all. I’m still in Thailand and our tax file is a huge mess. I’ll deal with it when I get back home. However, I just learn about an excellent tax strategy for wealthy old investors. Most of us aren’t rich and old, but we all hope to be in that position someday. When you get there, this tax strategy might be a great benefit to you.
Alright, just how wealthy are we talking about here? Let me explain the strategy and then work through a scenario.
The key to this tax strategy is the securities-based line of credit (SBLOC.) Basically, you can borrow money from your brokerage using your investment portfolio as collateral. When we retire, we plan to sell off some of our stock investment to generate income to fund our cost of living. However, once you are wealthy enough, using an SBLOC instead of selling your investment could generate significant tax savings. Someone named this the “buy, borrow, die” strategy. I guess that’s somewhat catchy.
Here are the reasons why this work.
- Selling stocks is a taxable event. When you sell, you’ll pay 15% to 20% capital gain tax. If your cost basis is low, you’ll pay quite a bit of tax.
- Getting an SBLOC and using the money isn’t a taxable event. You pay interest to the bank, but no tax. Your investment stays in your portfolio and you continue to benefit from the gains in the market.
- The cost basis reset when you die. This is the other important part of the equation. You’ll have to set up an estate. The estate will sell part of your portfolio to pay off the SBLOC debt when you go. The estate won’t have to pay the capital gain tax. You’ll need to work with a good tax advisor to set up a trust.
Those are the main points. You avoid the long-term capital gain tax, but you’ll have to pay interest to the bank. However, it won’t make sense for everyone. When I learn about this tax minimization technique, I was a bit skeptical. Avoiding the capital gain tax is nice, but the interest will compound. This will only work for old rich people. The interest will eat up the portfolio if you live too long. Right?
Let’s crunch some numbers.
Fred is 75 years old and he is in good health. His portfolio is worth $10 million. Most of the gains are taxable because he has been an investor for 60 years. Fred wants to sell $400,000 worth of investment to fund his cost of living. He’ll pay the 15% long-term capital gain tax and have about $340,000 to spend for the first year.
For the SBLOC option, he’ll have to borrow $340,000 and enough to pay the interest for the first year. From my research, the brokerages usually charge the prime interest rate. That’s about 7.5% right now. That’s higher than normal. In previous years, the prime rate was around 4-5%.
We’ll increase the cost of living to account for inflation each year.
After crunching the numbers, the timeline isn’t a significant factor in the equation. That’s a surprise to me. The other numbers are much more important. Here are the variables we need.
- The prime interest rate. This is how much interest you’ll pay on the loans.
- The portfolio gains rate. This is how much your portfolio will grow each year.
Here are some charts.
Scenario 1: low interest rate, good portfolio gains
The first one is the ideal scenario. The interest rate is 4% and the portfolio gains 8% annually. Using the SBLOC will give Fred an extra $2,000,000 after 10 years. I set inflation to 3% here.
Scenario 2: High interest rate, stagnate portfolio
Next, let’s see a more difficult scenario. I set the interest rate to 7.5%. That’s what the prime rate was in December 2022. Fred became very conservative and his portfolio gains just 1% annually. The inflation is set at 7%. In this tough scenario, Fred lost $1,500,000 from using the SBLOC.
Scenario 3: portfolio gains = prime rate
In the last scenario, I set the interest rate to be the same as the portfolio gains. The SBLOC method came out ahead by about $700,000.
From messing around with the parameters, I found that inflation and the timeline don’t really matter that much.
To make this strategy work, Fred’s portfolio must outperform the prime rate. This is the most important point. Fred’s $10,000,000 portfolio stays intact and the gains outpace the interest he has to pay.
This shouldn’t be too difficult to pull off. The stock market usually outperforms the prime rate significantly. However, some years can be very bad as well. In 2022, the S&P 500 lost nearly 20% and the prime rate was higher than usual. However, it seems the SBLOC strategy would win in the long haul. The stock market has many more good years than bad years.
The other issue is Fred is paying the big bank to make this work. Instead of helping the country by paying taxes, he’s enriching himself and other wealthy people. That doesn’t seem right.
Alright, I hope to be old and rich someday, but I’m not sure if I’ll use this strategy. You’ll probably come out ahead, but there are risks too. Also, I don’t really like paying a huge amount of interest to the big bank. I’d rather pay tax. But who knows? I might change my mind when I’m really rich…
What do you think? Is this a good tax strategy?
*Passive income is the key to early retirement. These days, I’m investing in commercial properties with CrowdStreet. They have many projects across the United States. It’s been working so well that I’m planning to sell our rental condo so I can invest more. Go check them out!
Disclosure: We may receive a referral fee if you purchase or signup for a service through the links on this page.
Image credit: Izzy Park
Passive income is the key to early retirement. This year, Joe is investing in commercial real estate with CrowdStreet. They have many projects across the USA so check them out!
Joe also highly recommends Personal Capital for DIY investors. They have many useful tools that will help you reach financial independence.